20601A-WFNZ-the-fan-Final2 35h_CBSSportsRad_1660AM

News Home

South Carolina Hospital To Allow Santa Back After Public Backlash

View Comments
File photo of Santa Claus. (credit: Jemal Countess/Getty Images for Lord & Taylor)

File photo of Santa Claus. (credit: Jemal Countess/Getty Images for Lord & Taylor)

CHARLESTON, S.C. (AP) — A Charleston Santa who was sent packing from a local hospital is one again unpacking his sack.

The Hollings Cancer Center of the Medical University of South Carolina said Wednesday volunteer Frank Cloyes may again dress up as Santa Claus to cheer patients.

Cloyes has been playing the role for two years, but on Tuesday was told his services weren’t needed because the hospital is affiliated with the state and there had been complaints from patients who were not Christian.

The hospital released a statement saying there was a “passionate response” from the public and patients after The Post and Courier ran a story about Santa’s firing.

The hospital now says it will allow holiday traditions of all faiths because of the emotional benefits they provide for patients.

(© Copyright 2011 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

View Comments
  • Kate

    Santa has nothing to do with religion. What is the matter with people? No matter what you do, someone will be “offended”. Whatever happened to being concerned with the majority? Several people can ruin it for everyone? It’s insane.

    • Bill

      Nothing to do with religion? He is “Saint Nicholas,” a Christian saint. Shows you how secularized he has become, people don’t even recognize him as the ancient Christian bishop that he was!

      • John Campbelll

        People know. It’s the Santa Claus name they forget. The Saintly Clause, as in good will towards men. Fact is Santa Claus is alive and well. It’s up to us to keep it that way.

        Those who find the need to make a public denial out of Santa Claus exhibit the hatred within themselves. Try to show them the true meaning of the Saintly Clause and they’ll recoil within their hate. It will take a lot of effort for someone so inclined to try to help them. They crave the attention their hated brings them. Without it they feel diminished and insignificant.

      • Michael Schuberth

        John Campbell: Well said!!!! Thank you

      • Conrad Mattson

        The Eastern Orthodox Christians do not have ‘cultural Santa Claus” like the west does giving toys and such on Christmas. They have St Nicholas Day on Dec 6. for that event. In fact most of Eastern Orthodox do not even have a traditional Christmas tree.

      • geronimo

        East is east, Conrad, and West is west, and even though the twain meet occasionally nowadays, they don’t mix very well. As a well-adjusted product of Western Civilization, American-style, I strongly favor preserving it. And I don’t care if it doesn’t meet with approval of Muslims, Eastern Orthodox Christians, Russians, Chinese or anybody else. The only reason voices are ever heard in opposition to the traditions of Western Civilization is because one of those traditions is to allow them to speak freely. In their world, anything in opposition is suppressed or silenced completely. That makes THEM the bigots, not us.

      • flashman1854

        So what??

        Great that he is Christian.

        We would NOT have an American nation without Christianity. Do you realize that?

        The founding fathers, 80%, were devout Christians.

        The First Amendment to the Constitution has been perverted to the point where it now enforces it’s OPPOSITE intention, to wit, allow the free exercise of religion.

        By the way, I am NOT a Christian. Do not attend church. And take no side for any religion. I am educated however, and facts are facts. Christianity was woven into the pattern of America’s founding. (Along with the Old Testament’s teachings, which are the core of the Jewish faith.). And without it there would not have been a United States of America.

      • Dark Space

        Bill – at best, Santa Claus (aka Saint Nicholas) is mythical character based on several different real and mythical characters. He certainly does not wholly represent the actual saint you refer too, and I would argue the one they’re talking about in this article, in his red suit, stories about elves in their workshop in the North Pole, and 9 reindeer, bears very little resemblance to that Saint…

        flashman1854 – please reveal your “facts”, especially the one about 80% of our founding fathers were devout Christians. Even if you remove the word devout and include people who only go to church at Easter in the “Christians” bucket, you’re going to have a hard time putting 80% of our founding fathers in that bucket. Based on your comments, you should start your education with Thomas Jefferson who was by and large the main contributor to the Declaration of Independence, openly critical of contemporary Christian churches, and heavily criticized much of their doctrine. You can start here: http://bit.ly/tVWHf1

      • mommaroo

        Thomas Jefferson was a Deist. To clarify, Deists believe in the existence of God, on purely rational grounds, without any reliance on revealed religion or religious authority or holy text. Not all of our Founding Fathers were Christians–or Jews. They all, however,did share a belief in God.

      • Obama’s Good Twin

        Dark Space,

        You’re mistaken. In reality, 52 of the 55 Founding Fathers were members of mainstream churches. Moreover, there are copious examples of statements made by them in which they attest to their faith. One well-know one is, “Our Constitution was made for a moral and religious people; it is wholly unfit for the governing of any other.” — John Adams, second president of these United States

      • Dark Space

        Don’t twist my words, I didn’t say anyone was godless. I would imagine that you would be hard pressed to find an Atheist in 18th century America. However, to imply that they were either “devout” or serious members of “mainstream churches” is blatantly incorrect and disagrees with all the historical facts. The vast majority, to mommaroo’s point, were Deists and believed in God, but most disagreed with mainstream churches and the leadership structure within the churches.

        Further, I would have a hard time assigning the word “devout Christian” to any of them. I assume your definition of this would be the same as most people’s, that a devout Christian is a true believer in J.C. and lives their life to the highest Christian standards… A) Let’s just stick with the 7 founding fathers everyone agrees on – I don’t think any one of them meet both those criteria, and most do not meet either one. Its hilarious you chose a quote from John Adams to support your incorrect statement that “52 of the 55 Founding Fathers were members of mainstream churches”. You really should pick up a book and read about the guy. He was a member of the Unitarian Church, and at least during his presidency regularly attended services – but he also very openly scorned all the more mainstream churches (Baptists, Presbyterian, Catholic, etc.) stating that they would not consider him a “Christian” anymore than he considered them true “Christians”.

      • Obama’s Good Twin

        Sorry, Dark, but as Daniel Moynihan once said, “You’re entitled to your own opinions, but you’re not entitled to your own facts.” Of the 55 Founding Fathers who worked on the Constitution, 52 were members of mainstream Christian churches. And while Deism was bigger then than it is today, to claim that the majority of them were Deists is utterly ridiculous. It was always a minority beliefs. From Wikipedia:

        “Deism was a religious philosophy in common currency in colonial times, and some Founding Fathers (most notably Thomas Paine, who was an explicit proponent of it, and Benjamin Franklin, who spoke of it in his Autobiography) are identified more or less with this system. Nevertheless, several early presidents are sometimes identified as holding deist tenets, though there is no president who identified himself as a deist. Although George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, James Monroe, and John Tyler are often identified as having some degree of deistic beliefs,[6] most of these identifications are controversial;[citation needed] Washington in particular maintained a life-long pattern of church membership and attendance, and there is conflicting testimony from those who knew him.”

      • Dark Space

        I doubt Moynihan envisioned that someone would use his line to support fact-gathering from Google and Wikipedia. Best of luck to you in all your endeavors though.

      • Obama’s Good Twin

        So where do you get your facts? From thin air?

        But your response is a tacit admission of defeat. It’s just too bad you’re not man enough to admit error explicitly.

      • Dark Space

        Sure, I’ll bite. I read books.

        I don’t think you and I are even having the same discussion, but we obviously disagree about what the basic facts are, so… I’m out. I wouldn’t call it defeat – I still think you’re completely off base, I’m just not interested in spending more time discussing it with you. Good luck spreading your version of history.

        I’m just glad Santa is back!

      • stevoh

        Who gives a rat fart. It’s really Krismas named after Kris Kringle, and I’m really PO’d they took the Kris out of Krismas.

    • elizabethrc

      When my children were in grammar school, one parent succeeded in getting Christmas trees removed from the schools. I still remember how disappointed my kids were. As un-PC as this may be, it was one Jewish mother who did this and I still remember her and the hateful act she authored and the unhappiness she created in a lot of children.

      Ben Stein wrote a remarkable piece about the obsession some non Christians have with the Christmas holidays. He has no problem with it, even enjoying the lights and festivities as well as the Menorah on display down the street. It was a sensitive and well thought out piece I wish everyone could read.

      The stronger non-Christians fight to neuter our Christmas observances, the stronger we are going to fight to keep them. I have head not a word against having Menorahs displayed, by the way. The fact that this is a Judeo-Christian country is not going to change and I think these people will find that we’ve been pushed as far as we intend to be pushed.

    • Erik

      Kate, while Santa in the US has largely become a secular figure used to promote consumption and consumerism, his origins go back to St. Nicklaus of Myra. In Europe many countries do not have Santa on Christmas Eve but St. Nicklaus Day December 6th.

    • Deneda

      Santa has never had alot to do with Christians, Santa has been broought down from generation to generation about what is wanted for Christmas. And from what I’ve seen alot of people and patients in hospitals love to see Santa come in, it lift’s up their spirit gives them something special to look forward to. But Santa is not related to being a christian and if you think so you have had a very upsetting childhood, all I say is God Bless you.

  • Dunce Biden

    To whomever complained about Santa. TOUGH!

    I complain about the the lying illegal-loving job-killing country destroyer in the White House but no one removes him (until Nov 2012 that is).

    If you don’t like Santa, head to Saudi Arabia. They are so very tolerant of other’s beliefs.

  • Dana

    This is exactly why God told the Jews not to mix with the occupants of the promised land on their exodus from Egypt. Multiculturalism is ultimately the death of every society. Thank God we have immigration quotas, or we may not even know our own country by now.

    • Paladin

      Dana,

      I see you’re not keeping abreast of what’s going on. Our “quotas” only ensure that 85 percent of our immigrants will come from the Third World and Asia. This is why the white population in the US has dropped from almost 90 percent in 1965 to only 63 percent today (and it dropped from 69 percent just during the last decade). The reality is that huge swaths of America already don’t look like the one our parents knew.

      Wake up.

    • Travis Blaylock

      like the tower of babel

    • Sam

      Comment’s like yours make me deeply sorry my Druid ancestors let the Christian missionaries in…

      • Fayrix

        The Druids didn’t let anyone in. Patrick came in and called down fire on their clover worshipping rears.

  • Mark Wright

    Why is it that Christians are asked to be, expected to be and are tolerant of non-Christians, but every whim of intolerant non- Christians are catered to?

    • Curly Bill

      Because hatred of Christianity and all that it stands for is now official government policy. Remind you of any place else in the last hundred years?

    • Nonion

      Well said and soooo true!

      Thanks.

    • Paladin

      I’ll answer your question. Because you’re dealing with evil people who won’t deal fairly or yield to reason. They only understand the power principle and need to be defeated.

      If you’re waiting for them to be fair or even compromise, you’ve fallen into their trap.

    • Noh McLachlan

      Good question Mark, it appears to be because 1/2 of 1% of the population now makes so much noise that everyone else is expected to fall in line with their wishes. America is no longer majority rule, it’s minority threat.

      I’ll let you guess who that 1/2 of 1% is and the first hint is “Mecca”.

  • Tara

    Good point, Mark Wright. Why can’t the people who hate Santa and Christmas just get with their own program and “be tolerant”?

    • Princess Tyra

      because they expect tolerance and never give it.

  • Reality Check

    Damn white of them to “allow it”.

    The “government affiliated” organization will allow religious celebrations of all faiths.

    More like the people who pay their pay checks let it be known that their political correctness was expendable. And so were they.

    • Princess Tyra

      because they expect tolerance of them…not from them

  • lookfortruth

    God Bless America–LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT!!! It is Satan who wants to destroy religion and Godly love in America. Think about whose side you are on because your eternal eternity is at stake.

  • Aaron Matthew Arnwine

    Ugh, do these folks have editors??? Error in the first sentence, “one again” should be “once again.” I should get paid to do this.

    • bubbles

      Paste it in a word doc. No squiggly lines = no problem – next!

      • SineQua0

        Of course, the trouble is, even that eludes them. ;P

      • Dark Space

        Actually, that wouldn’t work in this case – they need to actually understand grammar because Word wouldn’t catch that kind of error.

        Not even a green squiggly line.

  • wncchester

    It requires total idiots (aka, ‘innerlecsul libbruls’) who have been educated far beyond their intelligence to think the magical Santa Claus has any significance to any religion at all. And it appears the hospital’s ‘objectors’ fit that description quite well, as it does to the hospital managers who groveled before the ignorant whiners.

  • ray leonard

    Don’t you just love religion and busy bodies
    Santa Claus (Kris Kringle) is a pagan ritual to celebrate the winter solistice.
    I feel sorrow for those so narrow minded people that take joy out of everything in the name of god (lower case deliberate)

    • Fayrix

      Interesting comment, seeing that it is the narrow minded atheist worldview like yours which was probably responsible for the rescinded invitation to Santa in the first place.

  • phillysmart

    I was offended by removing Santa…whoever don’t like it tough….every year we see some idiots try to undermine our traditions. f them

  • Obama’s Good Twin

    This is what happens when you elect a de facto atheist to the presidency.

    Our family has always been ashamed of my brother. He’s always been the black sheep of the family.

    And he used to kick me in the womb.

    • Barbara Baxter

      Wow – generalize much? I’m an atheist, and I love Santa!

      • Obama’s Good Twin

        Barbara,

        I know my brother. He is an atheist who looks down on people of faith and reserves special hatred for Christianity.

        This is why he kicked me in the womb. I believed in God, but he didn’t, even though we had just come from God shortly before.

        But he’s always had a terrible memory, which is why he talks about 57 states.

      • PowerPC

        He is not an atheist. He is a faithful servant of allah and always will be…..(lower case intended!)

      • Suzanne

        Atheist… who cares? Your creator cares…and though you may not acknowledge and love God, he loves you…that’s why there is Christmas. John 3:16 says “For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son” It means to me, “For God so loves the world that he gave us Christmas”….And atheists, DO NOT lecture me with your pseudo intellectualism. I’ve heard ALL of your rhetoric….What will you say on your deathbed? “Accountant, have mercy on my soul”, “greed and banker, have mercy on my soul”, “college professor, have mercy on my soul”.”No, you will say, Lord, have mercy on my soul”. You don’t believe? You don’t believe yet, you just haven’t gotten into your foxhole!

      • steve

        The celebration on 12/25 was originally pagan. You guys are celebrating a pagan hioliday. Don’t you feel stupid? Jesus was born no where near 12/25 because that would be winter and shepherds wouldn’t be standing by their sheep after dusk. Suzanne, when I die, i’ll just die. I won’t be praying to some make believe character to allow me entry into some make believe place for eternity. If I did, I’d be praying to the one giving me access to 72 virgins.

  • Mike Alright

    While I am glad that that Santa is back-feminized America will continue to fall. And once it does women will lose their unappreciated special rights.

    • Obama’s Good Twin

      Mike,

      You’re a very astute man. When the feminists and others succeed in fully collapsing the West, there will be an adjustment. And women will be put back in the kitchen whether they like it or not.

      Male dominance is the default.

      • Eliot

        Actually, if the Muslims succeed in getting sharia law accepted in this country (and they are trying) women will be worse than slaves. I joined a group called Women for Women International, which helps poor women from Muslim countries to start businesses; the group has to get permission not only from the woman’s husband, but from the village leaders, as well, just to give a woman a couple of goats. And the many reports of disfigurement and death at the hands of husbands would curl your hair.

  • CommonCents

    “…and there had been complaints from patients who were not Christian.”

    It was most likely a Jew… or a crypto-Jew who is ‘posing’ as an atheist.

    Same people who keep trying to ban Christmas trees & nativity scenes.

    • RuRu

      I do not believe a Jewish person complained. Your hatred of Jews is abominable.Why don’t you just stop with your guessing games, crypto-jew What is wrong with you!!!

    • Dernon Ruton

      Now, here was an innocuous little story about some person having a bad day, and who was oversensitive about Santa. Silly, no big deal. Santa was invited back just as soon as the protests “for” outnumbered the protest “against.” Fine. But then you amble in like the DNA-damaged misfit hyena you are, and muck it up with Jew-hatred from left field. You don’t have a prayer of living up to your name, I’ve got news for you, buster. Where’d you get your Jew problem? Let’s see you wet yourself when the Muslims come for you, tough guy.

  • Solid Citizen

    We know who the “Santa” is… A good reporter would tell us a bit more about the faceless bureaucrat (aka Grinch)

    quo warranto,B.O.?

  • RuRu

    I think we allowed too many immigrants into this country that do not want to become Americans. They come here and then want us to change. I SAY NO. This is America come here and become American or stay the Heck out!!! People used to want to be here to enjoy our Freedoms, Now they come here and want to take our Freedoms away. NO, NO, NO!!

    • fartburger

      PLEASE OH PLEASE!!!!! PLEASE ! Get the difference between immigrant and illegal immigrant. The media, schools and the anti american federal government have been successful in erasing the difference between the two in the minds of the american people.

      • Obama’s Good Twin

        FB,

        Here is usually the difference: An illegal immigrant is an unassimilable Third Worlder who comes here without the official sanction of the US government.

        A llegal immigrant is an unassimilable Third Worlder who comes here with the official sanction of the US government.

        Both usually vote for socialists upon being naturalized.

        Both usually have no use for our traditions.

        You were saying?

  • Ohiowordguy

    I’m gonna go on record as saying there was no complaint. My guess is some administrator with an anti-Christmas and/or Christian bias made a unilateral decision. I’d be willing to bet money on it.

    If indeed this is a public/state-affiliated hospital then such complaints could be public record,right? Hmmm…

    P.S. It is a fact that 92 percent or more of Americans celebrate Christmas, whether or not they celebrate it as a religious holiday. I’m guessing that in South Carolina the percentage is even higher.

    • fartburger

      Good call. As a result of this mess I have made the decision to never give another cent to ANY charity affiliated with cancer research or care. I would not want to offend the other charities I don’t give to by continuing to give to these creeps.
      Gee, look, Ma, I can be PC too.

  • Phillip

    I love it when the ACLUE loses and the good guys win.

  • DawnJ

    Now, you’re gettin’ it, Hollings–inclusion, not exclusion. PC run amok.

  • John Svengali

    Good. This is the United States of America. Santa Claus is welcome!

    I hope they learned.

  • DawnJ

    “there had been complaints from patients who were not Christian”

    Bull! I’ll bet anything that it was one or two joyless idiots. I hear about the tyranny of the majority. What about the tyranny of the minority? Here you have a tradition that harms nobody. On the contrary, it brings joy to people who are suffering. Yet, we will bow down to one or two miserable jerks, who are determined to make sure everybody else is as miserable as they.

  • Galzu

    merry christmyth one and all

    • Princess Tyra

      wow…your one of the two joyless idiots.Troll…

    • Fayrix

      Shouldn’t you be out watching Zeitgeist on Youtube from your Touchpad and engaging in anal intercourse with your beau?

      Leave the comment sections to the grownups with jobs, please.

    • Fayrix

      @Gaizu

      And in other news, L Ron Hubbard called and wants his worldview back.

  • Al Tango

    Liberals should not be in charge of anything. They are too dumb to realize how dumb they are.

  • potvin

    You should have seen what happened when the Easter Bunny showed up there.

  • Dont Whine

    I really hope the government employee that had nothing better to do than try to mess with the public and assert his or her authority over us is made to pay for their arrogance.

    They must really think very little of the visitors to the center if they think that someone of differing or no faith is unable to appreciate the well meaning traditions of another faith.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Follow CBS Charlotte

Like us on foursquare